GermGuardian Reviews | Vacuum Wars

In this Air Purifier Wars comparison, we have a matchup that puts two best-selling air purifiers to the test: the Levoit Core 300 vs the GermGuardian AC4825E. These are two of the most popular air purifiers in the world, and we’re excited to see which comes out on top. We put them both through a rigorous series of evaluations over the period of a few weeks, including some all-new tests, and the results were really interesting. About the GermGuardian AC4825E This GermGuardian air purifier is one of the AC4825 models. The E designates that it is black in color. The GermGuardian AC4825W is the same air purifier in white. It purifies air with a HEPA filter, a carbon filter, and UV-C light, and GermGuardian says it is effective for up to a 743-square-foot room. GermGuardian AC4825E Air Purifier Amazon How do we know it’s popular? It has no less than 48,000 reviews on Amazon at the time of publishing this review and comparison! The GermGuardian is also Energy Star certified. About the Levoit Core 300 Like the GermGuardian, Levoit kept costs down with the Core 300 by using a simple approach: offer an air purifier without smart features. Without the need for WiFi or other advanced electronics, an air purifier is far less expensive to manufacture, meaning it can be sold for a much lower price. Levoit Core 300 Air Purifier Amazon Levoit does sell a Wifi-enabled, smart version called the Levoit Core 300S (see the difference between the Core 300 and Core 300S). The Core 300 also has a HEPA filter and carbon filter and is available in black or white. Levoit says the ideal room size for the Core 300 is 219 square feet, although they also suggest it can be used in larger rooms, too. It might be hard to find an air purifier with more reviews than the Core 300 on Amazon. The number of reviews on the product page at last check was over 85,000! The Core 300 has several industry certifications, including CARB compliance, Energy Star certification, FCC certification, ETL listing, and CA PROP 65 certification. GermGuardian AC4825E and Levoit Core 300 side-by-side. © Vacuum Wars GermGuardian AC4825E vs Levoit Core 300 These air purifiers are similar in many ways, which is why they're a good fit for a head-to-head competition. For example, they're both budget air purifiers, and while the GermGuardian is currently a little less expensive than the Levoit Core 300, they're both in a similar, very low price range. RELATED: Importance of Activated Carbon Filters in Air Purifiers. They also have similar official room size recommendations, though the Levoit is slightly larger. Finally, as mentioned above, both air purifiers share the same basic air purification techniques using HEPA filters to catch particulates and carbon filters to eliminate smells, gases, and VOCs. Both air purifiers and their filters. © Vacuum Wars Although they have similar methods of purifying the air, our filtration evaluations showed there were some differences in the quality and speed of that air purification. One standout difference is that the GermGuardian is the only one with a UV-C light that shines on the filter. The UV-C light can be turned on or off by pressing a button atop the unit. Air purifier resources Best Air Purifiers NEW – See which air purifiers we chose as the best after putting over 30 models through our tests. Air Purifier Reviews - See recent reviews and comparisons of the top air purifier models. We left it enabled, and it didn't seem to make much of a difference in our evaluations. Air purifiers with UV-C lights use them with the principle that UV-C light would kill any viruses or bacteria that are caught on the filter. Features The first category we will look at is features. These are things that don't necessarily help with air purification but are nice to have. As these are both budget air purifiers, there wasn't all that much in the way of features. They both have three fan speed settings, and they both have a change filter indicator. The Levoit is the only one with a timer, as well as a sleep mode. The Levoit Core 300 and GermGuardian AC4825E before our tests. © Vacuum Wars We also include their size in the feature category, where smaller is always better, and here, the Levoit is both shorter and has fewer cubic inches overall. So, the Levoit wins the features round. Filter Quality The next round is filter quality. They both have HEPA filters rated at the exact same 99.97 percent at 0.3 microns. But the Core 300 had more HEPA filter material than the GermGuardian did, meaning that you would need to replace the Levoit filter less often than the GermGuardian's. However, in the end, it kind of evens out since the replacement cost for the Levoit’s filter is about 40 percent more expensive. They both have a carbon filter layer for filtering out odors, gases, and volatile organic compounds. How each air purifier goes about that layer of filtration varies. The Levoit has actual pieces of activated charcoal, even if it's not that much of it, whereas the GermGuardian just has a mesh layer that's been treated with activated carbon. The treated approach is of a much lower quality, and it may come back to bite the GermGuardian in the VOC tests later on. We saw this exact same difference in the Air Purifier Wars comparison of the Coway Airmega AP-1512HH and Winix 5500-2. Levoit's (left) filter vs GermGuardian's (right). © Vacuum Wars In the image above, you can see the black media on the inside of the Levoit Core 300's cylindrical filter and on the flat GermGuardian filter. The Levoit was also the only one that offered other filter options. For example, you can buy an upgraded filter with the Core 300 if you're more concerned with VOCs or odors. We bought one of those too, and we'll reveal if there was any difference later in the VOC tests. Airflow and noise tests The next round is bench evaluations. This is where we measure things like airflow and noise level. The Levoit Core 300 had slightly more airflow on max power than the GermGuardian did. Levoit Core 300GermGuardian AC4825EFan Speed 148db @ 38 cfm51db at 46 cfmFan Speed 254db @ 49 cfm59db @ 60 cfmFan Speed 365db @ 74 cfm65db @ 68 cfmAirflow to noise test results are from Vacuum Wars' own testing, not the manufacturers. As far as noise goes, we measured the same noise level on max power, meaning that the Levoit also had a slightly better airflow-to-noise ratio. But really, the scores for both airflow and noise were very similar, with a slight edge to the Levoit. Filtration Tests Let's move on to the filtration evaluations. The first test we do is the fog test, where we release 12 seconds of fog into a ventless room and run the air purifier on max power. Here, performance was almost identical, reducing the 10 and 2.5 micron particles at almost the exact same speed, with a slight edge to the Levoit Core 300. The GermGuardian cleared the air during our fog evaluation. © Vacuum Wars But there was a significant difference with our VOC test. VOC stands for volatile organic compounds. We test this by pumping exact amounts of incense smoke into a sealed refrigerator and measuring how much and how quickly the air purifier can reduce the VOCs in a five-minute test on max power. As far as our matchup goes, the Levoit was able to reduce the TVOCs by 55 percent in five minutes, whereas the GermGuardian was only able to reduce them by 12 percent in five minutes. The performance was similar to the formaldehyde test. Taking VOC measurements as the Levoit Core 300 performs our VOC test. © Vacuum Wars As mentioned before, we also tested the Levoit's upgraded filter, which is sold separately, and it did about 25 percent better, getting 76 percent of the TVOCs in the five-minute test. So here, we can see that the GermGuardian's cheaper carbon filter really was noticeable, and the UV light doesn't do much to help with this since it's only supposed to kill live bacteria caught on the HEPA filter. Winner: Levoit Core 300 After adding up all the scores from all the rounds, the Levoit Core 300 beat the GermGuardian 88-45, which is kind of a blowout. BEST CHOICE Levoit Core 300 Amazon RUNNER-UP GermGuardian AC4825E Amazon The Levoit Core 300 has better features, filters, performance, and it did better in the filtration test. So, it really is a no-brainer winner for this super budget price range. The Levoit Core 300 wins, easily outscoring the GermGuardian AC4825E. © Vacuum Wars Specs ManufacturerGermGuardianLevoitModelAC4825E/AC4825WCore 300HEPA FilterYesYesCarbon FilterCoatingPiecesUV-C LightOptionalNoEnergy Star Certified *YesYesEnergy Star Room Size *153 sqft217 sqftSmoke Free CADR*99 cfm140 cfmDust Free CADR*118 cfm141 cfmPollen Free CADR*125 cfm145 cfmSmart FeaturesNoNoDimensions22” x 10.25” x 6.75”8.7” x 8.7” x 14.2”Weight8.6 lb7.5 lbFan Speeds33Warranty3 years2 yearsWhere to BuyAmazonAmazonSpecs are from the manufacturer’s website with the exception of fields marketing with a * which is from Energy Star.

Our Top Picks

No items found.