At Vacuum Wars, we are dedicated to providing the most thorough and insightful vacuum cleaner reviews. This commitment is embodied in our detailed and specialized testing methods designed to assess various aspects of vacuum performance, from basic suction to more complex tasks like hair entanglement and battery efficiency.
We do not claim that our testing methods are the gold standard, or anywhere near true laboratory tests, but they are our best efforts at honestly and fairly evaluating the relative differences in these products from a consumer advocate perspective. And we have many years of data from doing these tests the same way over and over for hundreds of products. So we can easily spot if a product is much better, or much worse than average. Each of these tests are carefully designed to mimic real-life situations that a vacuum might encounter, ensuring that our reviews are both comprehensive and useful to consumers.
Here's an in-depth look at our upright vacuum testing methods:
In our "unsealed suction test," AKA “usable suction” we have connected a digital manometer to a specially designed testing surface so that we can evaluate the real-world upright vacuum suction performance. This approach allows us to take into account the entire design of the vacuum cleaner, in particular the influence of the floor head elements, such as air gates and the seal created by certain elements on the bottom of the floorhead. These factors play a crucial role in the vacuum’s cleaning efficiency. This test is done on max power, and the highest score (in Kpa) is recorded. We like it because its not just about raw power but vacuum engineering as well.
We measure airflow using a digital anemometer, which calculates the volume of air passing through the vacuum in cubic feet per minute (CFM). Airflow is the stream of air that moves through the vacuum cleaner, carrying dust and debris from the cleaning surface into the vacuum and through to the dust collection system. Higher airflow means that more air is moving through the vacuum, which can carry more particles and larger debris with it. Essentially, better airflow results in better overall performance, though this is not always the case. We focus on measuring airflow at the brush and any other operational configurations such as from a detachable hose, or at the wand, in order to understand how the vacuum performs in diverse household scenarios. We typically measure the airflow in all of the power settings of the vacuum, though our scores are based on the maximum power setting.
At Vacuum Wars, our filtration tests assess how effectively vacuum cleaners can enhance indoor air quality and control allergens, which is especially crucial for individuals with allergies, asthma, or other respiratory issues. Using a fog machine, we visually confirm the effectiveness of the vacuum's filtration system and its capacity to contain vacuumed particles. This approach allows us to directly observe and evaluate the vacuum's ability to prevent these particles from re-entering the home environment, thereby providing a clear and tangible assessment of its filtration performance.
In our Carpet Deep Clean Test, we evaluate a vacuum’s ability to pick up fine debris that settles below a carpet’s top surface area, becoming embedded between the carpet fibers. In this test, we apply 100 grams of sand to an area of medium-pile carpet, and we work the sand into the carpet fibers to ensure that the sand has come to rest below the surface of the carpet. The vacuum is run over the carpet a set number of passes at the same basic rate of motion. These tests are performed on the vacuum’s maximum power setting. If the vacuum has adjustable gates, the tests are performed with the gates set to their lowest setting.
After vacuuming, the content of the vacuum’s dustbin is weighed to determine how much sand has been picked up. We typically run this test at least three times to ensure accuracy. A perfect score of 100 indicates that all the embedded material was removed from the carpet.
The crevice pickup test is an assessment of the vacuum’s power and floorhead design, showing its ability to effectively vacuum debris that can collect in the cracks and crevices of a floor’s surface, such as seams, transitions, or tile grout.
In this test, we apply coffee grounds over a specially designed testing surface that has a ¼ inch deep crevice and a 1/8 inch deep crevice. We run the vacuum over it once at its highest setting, with adjustable gates closed if applicable. Vacuums that collect all of the debris from both crevices get a perfect score.
In the Surface Debris Pickup Test, we assess how well vacuums pick up debris on hard floor and carpet without needing to adjust their settings. We use various sizes of debris, such as fine coffee grounds to the largest items such as cereal. The aim is to assess both the effectiveness and the aesthetics of the cleaning, ensuring that vacuums can handle everyday messes across different surfaces.
We take away points for issues like:
The Anti-Hair Wrap Test challenges vacuums to handle 1 gram of 7-inch and 14-inch hair without getting it tangled in the brush roll. This test is crucial for understanding how well the vacuum deals with hair, a common issue for many homeowners, especially those with pets. In this test we lay the hair before the vacuums, run a pass over the hair, and then visually inspect the roller for hair tangles. Vacuums with no hair tangles receive a perfect score.
During our vacuum testing process, we assess the vacuums in a simulated household environment that includes common obstacles such as chair legs, low furniture, and area rugs. Our focus is to evaluate whether the vacuum navigates easily across both hard floors and carpets and if it can be smoothly steered around furniture. This testing helps determine the vacuum's maneuverability and overall ease of use in typical home settings.
We specifically test the lift-away capabilities of various upright vacuums, which are sometimes referred to as lift-up features. This functionality allows the main unit of the vacuum to detach from the floor head, enabling users to clean hard-to-reach areas more effectively. Importantly, some models offer a powered lift-away option, where the floor head remains active and motorized even when detached.
Our testing focuses on the ease of use of these lift-away mechanisms and their overall effectiveness in everyday cleaning scenarios. We assess how seamlessly these vacuums transition from traditional upright operation to their lift-away state and back, ensuring that these features enhance the vacuum’s versatility without compromising performance.
We also award points for the inclusion of features that enhance the functionality and effectiveness of cordless vacuums. These feature assessments include:
When we have completed our evaluations of a vacuum, we log and track the results according to our established upright vacuum testing standards. This structured approach enables us to compare the performance of each vacuum against others we have tested within the same category. By doing so, we can tailor our recommendations based on specific criteria such as price category, floor type, and features. This methodical comparison ensures that our vacuum performance testing and recommendations are objectively grounded, providing a consistent, fair, and unbiased framework for our analysis.
Vacuum Wars has made a significant shift towards complete independence by officially adopting a policy of not accepting free products from companies or doing sponsored content. This ensures that all reviews are based on products purchased with our own funds, thereby eliminating any potential bias that might come from manufacturer influence.
When choosing between bagged and bagless vacuums, consider your household's specific needs and preferences for debris disposal. Consumers have voiced the following opinions about bagged and bagless vacuum cleaners:
Bagless vacuums collect debris in a removable dustbin that is then emptied into a trash receptacle. Some consumers are concerned about potential re-exposure to dust and allergens that may recirculate into the air during the emptying process.
Bagged vacuums, on the other hand, capture debris in disposable bags that also serve as additional filtration layers. These bags are discarded and replaced when full, providing a hygienic solution that minimizes re-exposure to dust and debris. Some consumers are concerned that the use of disposable bags contributes to landfill waste and involves ongoing costs for new bags.
The choice between upright and cordless vacuums depends on your specific needs.
Upright vacuums, typically corded, offer continuous power, which supports more powerful motors, larger floor heads, and bigger dustbins. Continuous power also allows for whole-household and large-area cleaning sessions all at once.
Cordless vacuums, on the other hand, boast portability and convenience, perfect for quick cleanups and shorter cleaning sessions, though they may require more frequent emptying due to their smaller dustbins. Some cordless vacuums may not perform as well on deep carpet cleaning, but there are recent and more powerful cordless models that outperform older upright vacuums.
Contemporary upright vacuums are often designed to effectively clean multiple floor types. Features like adjustable suction and brush roll settings allow them to transition from hardwood floors to carpets without hassle. Vacuums with more power often do well at deep cleaning carpets and collecting debris from crevices. Always check the manufacturer’s guidelines to ensure suitability for delicate surfaces like hardwood and delicate rugs.
Vacuums equipped with specialized pet hair removal technologies, such as silicone brush rolls or higher suction settings, tend to perform better on pet hair. Models that include anti-hair wrap features and those with powerful filtration systems are particularly effective. Look for vacuums that specifically mention pet hair capabilities in their feature list.
Yes, many upright vacuums come with attachments such as upholstery tools and crevice tools that make them suitable for cleaning curtains, upholstery, and other above-floor areas. Models with a hose and wand provide extended reach for these tasks. Check the specific features of your model to ensure it includes the necessary tools for such cleaning jobs.
Depending on usage and the manufacturer’s recommendations, filters should generally be replaced every 6 to 12 months. If the filter is washable, be sure to clean it regularly, and if the vacuum is used heavily or in a pet-friendly household it may need to be both washed and replaced more frequently. Regular checks will help maintain optimal vacuum performance.
Regular maintenance of an upright vacuum includes:
Loss of suction often results from a clogged hose, full dustbin, or blocked filters. Start by emptying the dustbin and checking the filters for blockages. Inspect the hose and attachments for obstructions. If the vacuum has adjustable gates or settings, ensure they are correctly configured for the surface being cleaned.
View additional details on the current Vacuum Wars Best Upright Vacuums. Read our review summary and discover the highlights as well as the pros and cons of each vacuum. Vacuum Wars provides an unbiased, independent evaluation for each (based our our proprietary vacuum testing methods.
The Shark PowerDetect swiftly became one of our favorites among upright vacuums, blending unparalleled power with groundbreaking features. Its exceptional performance in picking up all types of debris and hair on various surfaces, coupled with innovative technologies like the DuoClean roller and Shark's active hair removal system, solidifies its position as a top performer. The addition of 'detect' features—such as Floor Detect and Edge Detect—enhances its usability by automating adjustments for different cleaning scenarios, making it smarter than its predecessors. The Powered Lift-Away feature remains a standout, offering versatility in cleaning reach and method. Although it's on the heavier side and priced at a premium, the comprehensive capabilities and ease of use presented by the Shark PowerDetect justify its position as a leader in the vacuum cleaner market.
We think that the Shark Stratos Powered Lift-Away is an exceptional performer in the premium vacuum category, boasting the strongest suction and airflow of any upright vacuum Shark has offered. Its DuoClean technology ensures top-tier performance on both carpets and hard floors, picking up everything from fine dust to large debris with ease. The new roller design enhances its carpet cleaning capabilities, making it the best Shark vacuum for deep cleaning carpets yet. It's equipped with advanced features like active hair removal, powered lift-away for versatile cleaning, and a complete seal HEPA filtration system, which effectively traps dust and allergens. The Stratos's power, combined with its innovative design, offers an unrivaled cleaning experience. See full review.
We think that the Dyson Ball Animal 3 is an impressive upgrade from its predecessors, boasting significant improvements in design and functionality. The new cleaner head with adjustable gates offers superior debris pickup on both hard floors and carpets, making it a more versatile option. Its enhanced maneuverability, combined with the whole machine HEPA filtration and a robust suction power, ensures a thorough clean. Additionally, the active hair removal system dramatically reduces tangles, setting this model apart as especially beneficial for pet owners. See full review.
We found that the Shark Rotator Pet Lift-Away ADV effectively combines potent suction and lightweight design into one powerful vacuum. With its innovative Lift-Away feature, it allows for easy cleaning of above-floor areas, while the Anti-Allergen Complete Seal with a HEPA filter ensures that dust and allergens are trapped inside the vacuum. The DuoClean PowerFins HairPro technology provides deep cleaning on carpets and direct engagement on hard floors for optimal debris removal. Additionally, the Odor Neutralizer Technology and advanced features like LED headlights and swivel steering enhance the vacuuming experience, making it efficient and user-friendly.
We think that the Shark Navigator Lift-Away NV352 is a triumph in budget vacuum design, demonstrating robust suction and versatile cleaning capabilities. Its well-designed swivel steering and light weight make it incredibly user-friendly, while the HEPA filtration and seal technology ensure that it effectively keeps dust and allergens contained. The Lift-Away feature adds significant versatility, allowing easy transition to cleaning stairs, upholstery, or other challenging areas. With its commendable performance on both carpet and hard floors, combined with a thoughtful attachment set, the NV352 offers exceptional value and functionality, standing the test of time as a beloved model in the vacuum cleaner market.
The current Vacuum Wars Best Upright Vacuums ranking based on our own independent evaluation.
At Vacuum Wars, we’ve tested and reviewed a plethora of vacuum cleaners, and while many top performers tend to be on the pricier side, today we’re focusing on those that deliver solid performance without breaking the bank. In this article, we’ll highlight our top budget-friendly vacuums across various categories.
The current Vacuum Wars Best Upright Vacuums ranking based on our own independent evaluation.